Tuesday, October 20, 2009

The abandoned heaven

Almost exactly five years ago, Hamish Dewe drove me to the Hokianga in a disintegrating car he had brought for a few hundred dollars immediately after getting off a flight from Beijing.

Hamish's years in China had begun with a semi-respectable job which saw him inflicting the pearls of English literature - Shakespeare, Dickens, Virginia Woolf, and, because the teacher had a good deal of input into the curriculum, Wyndham Lewis - on the recalcitrant students of a provincial university, and then devolved into a series of train, bus, and truck journeys into ever more remote areas of the country, journeys which were interspersed with gigs at English language schools staffed by permanently hungover Western slackers who liked to let students broaden their vocabularies by playing endless games of scrabble.

Hamish had turned up without warning in his clapped-out car and ordered me into the navigator's seat, which was brimming with the freshly-dogeared books he had bought, or at least acquired, in a bid to catch up with the recent course of New Zealand literature. Hamish does not so much read books as absorb them into his bloodstream. He likes to demonstrate his mastery of a novel by unsympathetically mimicking the traits of its minor characters; he often gives his opinion of a volume of poems by reciting its lines in more or less sarcastic tones.

Hamish told me that he travelled across China with copies of Ezra Pound's epic poem The Cantos and Wyndham Lewis' equally fat satirical novel The Apes of God; the book's heavy covers had come in handy when he had kipped down on the benches of parks or railway stations and needed somewhere to rest his head. I wondered if the texts between the covers had somehow managed to seep into Hamish's sleeping head through some process resembling osmosis, because he seemed to be able to recite endless passages of Pound's allusive, multilingual verse and Lewis' turgid prose from memory as we travelled northwest, past the little towns at the foot of the Byrnderwyns and into the flat country south of Dargaville.

On the top of the pile of Hamish's recently-acquired books was a cover divided into blocks of black, white, and orange. On the cover's block of white, under the title Atua Wera, was a drawing of a creature with the body of a lizard, a long, sharp tail, and wings that looked like billowing sails. The placenames Hokianga, Pakanae, Waimamauku, and Wairoa had been scribbled underneath the strange creature by John Webster, the Hokianga trader who had drawn it in 1855after attending secret religious meetings. For Hamish and his yawning navigator, the list represented an itinerary: we were going north, to visit some of the locations of Kendrick Smithyman's posthumously-published epic poem about the religious movement founded by the nineteenth century tohunga and rebel Papahurihia.

By October 2004, Atua Wera had been in print for eight years, Smithyman had been dead for nearly nine years, and both the poet and his longest poem were beginning to get the serious critical attention they deserved. Somewhere underneath Hamish's copy of Atua Wera was a copy of the special issue that the literary journal brief had recently devoted to Smithyman.
brief editor Jack Ross had filled Smithymania with academic essays, memoirs from family and friends, interviews, photographs, and dirty limericks. Somebody had given Hamish a copy of Smithymania, and he had set about reading it with his usual ruthlessness.

Hamish was steering us around a slight bend in Highway 12 and reciting a passage from the Pisan Cantos when he suddenly slammed his foot on the brake, so that our vehicle almost collided with an upturned concrete trough half-hidden in the long grass beside the road. 'That's it, the church! That's the church on the cover!' he shouted, digging around in the pile of volumes at my feet. When Hamish extracted his copy of Smithymania, and gestured through the cloud of lime-dust in front of our windscreen, I understood: the small church on the building's cover sat a few hundred yards from us, surrounded by weedy paddocks and a grove of totara.

Like most of the other images in Smithymania, the cover photo was the work of Michael Dean, a young man who had travelled around the north in the late '90s snapping scenes for his friend Jack Ross, who was trying to persuade Creative New Zealand to fund a book of images and text called Kendrick Smithyman's Northland. Funding had not been forthcoming, and Dean's photos had lain unseen until Jack had excavated them for Smithymania. As Hamish and I walked down a gravel road to the little church, we argued about the role the building might have played in Smithyman's life and writing. With its lack of external adornment, small size, and high very steep roof, the church looked Anglican. Smithyman had spent the first decade of his life in Te Kopuru, an old timber milling town just south of Dargaville, and about half an hour from Ruawai.

Perhaps, I suggested, the Smithyman family had sometimes attended this church? Impossible, Hamish snapped: Smithyman's father had been a wharfie who was a member of the 'Red' Federation of Labour and supporter of the Industrial Workers of the World during the revolutionary years before the First World War, and later a staunch Labour Party man. He was a socialist with no interest in the opium of the people. It is true, I conceded, that I couldn't think of any Smithyman poems about attending church as a child. Perhaps the poet visited and wrote about the church as an adult? Smithyman's always-intense apprehension of history was often heightened by the mildewed churches of his native Northland. Were we walking in the old boy's footsteps? Hamish was constructing a condemnation of Anglicanism, and of the 'nation of shopkeepers' that gave the faith its start, when we eased open a flaking red door and took a couple of steps forward, expecting to find the normal, cosy Anglican interior, with its large varnished cross, its pulpit painted with familiar Bible scenes by the local youth group, and a black and white portrait of the Queen hung in a corner by an embarrassed pastor. Instead, we found ourselves standing on a dirty floor, amidst scattered and broken benches, staring at a rising sun and a series of five-pointed stars cupped in crescent moons. We were looking at a painted map of the universe constructed by Tahupotiki Wiremu Ratana, the farmer from the Whanganui district who became the mangai - that is, the mouthpiece - of God in November 1918, after two whales beached themselves at the bottom of his property and an angel descended from heaven to talk with him.

Hamish and I turned on our heels, following the orbit of the heavenly bodies around the walls of the little church, and squinting at the strange words painted beneath them. Arepa. Alpha. Omeka. Omega. Wairua Tapu. Sacred Spirit. Anahera Pono. Faithful angels.

In an essay he collected in his 2008 Auckland University Press volume Waimarino County and Other Excursions, Martin Edmond described the experience of entering a Ratana temple at Raetihi, down the road from his childhood home of Ohakune:

Inside was a little piece of heaven. The same segmented five-pointed star inside the cusp of the crescent moon was carved into the pew ends. Each segment of the star has its own colour: blue for the Father, white for the Son, red for the Holy Ghost; purple for the Angels and gold for the Mangai, T. W. Ratana. Everything in the church was painted, even the altar, which was strewn with flowers.

The first and largest Ratana temple was completed in 1928, in the village that grew on the farm of the movement's founder. With its Romanesque style and the crescent moon and star on top of each of its pillars, Te Temepera Tapu o Iha (the Holy Temple of Jehovah) became the prototype for temples in Raetihi and a series of other towns and villages where the poor and politically marginalised Maori who adopted Ratana's faith lived. Almost uniquely, the little Ratana temple near Ruawai was established in the shell of an earlier, European house of worship. In her new book on Maori architecture, Deidre Brown argues that the Ratana appropriation of a European Catholic style is an example of whakanoa, the ancient practice of denigrating the mana of opponents. In pre-contact times, iwi had sometimes stolen the waka of rivals and violated the mana and tapu of these craft by transferring their carvings to buildings that stored food. In a somewhat similar way, Brown argues, Ratana and his builders sought to undermine the cultural authority and appropriate the mana of European Christianity by adopting the Romanesque style. Despite its location, the temple Hamish and I visited does not seem to have figured in Kendrick Smithyman's writing. It may have been the photographer Robin Morrison, not Smithyman, who inspired Michael Dean to pause beside the little building. Dying of cancer, the popular and prolific Morrison made a final visit to Northland in 1992, and returned with a series of images of graves, angels, and churches which were published posthumously in a book titled A Journey. One of the less spectacular images in Morrison's book shows the temple near Ruawai framed by mist, dark totara and an overcast sky. Like much of the work in A Journey, the photograph suggests a connection to place, and a sense of permanence that is deeply poignant, given Morrison's circumstances in 1992.

In Michael Dean's photograph, the temple near Ruawai is brightly lit, and surrounded by long, dry grass. Although it is superficially different from Morrison's wintry image, Dean's photo communicates a similar sense of solidity and belonging. He has shot the temple from a low angle and at a distance, making it look like the structure grows naturally out of the landscape, and obscuring mildewed panels and other signs of neglect and decay. A few months after he encountered the Ratana temple, Hamish Dewe returned suddenly to China. Hamish's departure came as something of a surprise to many of his friends, because the depravity of Chinese capitalism and the hideousness of Chinese cities had been favourite topics of conversation for him during his stay in New Zealand. Instead of the lengthy, excited epistles that most travellers to exotic places send home to their friends, Hamish delivered a series of laconic, caustic poems to the editors of brief documenting his latest travels. In a poem which was published in a 2005 issue of brief, a memory of New Zealand rubbed against a report from China:

Arepa. Omeka.

Knocking, wait for no answer,
for no answer’s coming.

The windows are broken, burnt
out cars are dumped in the field
a horse once grazed.
Lace curtains at the
verandah wave in the breeze.
Inhabitants? None. The church,
Ratana, shows hoof-prints in
its sodden field.

Without holding hands, we pass
through the hospital, which smells
of herbs and urine, comforting,
out to the street. Liu Wu’s consumption
has passed. The one-kuai bus
takes us down to the station,
and we’re gone.

I'm not sure if Hamish has ever seen Robin Morrison's photograph of the Ratana temple, and I don't know what he thought about Michael Dean's image, but I can't help thinking of 'Arepa. Omeka.' as a rebuke to the two men's vision of the little building near Ruawai. At the beginning of his poem, Hamish knocks on the door of the abandoned building, aware of the absurdity of his gesture. Like the non-believer in Philip Larkin's famous poem 'Churchgoing', who removes his bicycle clips in 'awkward reverence' when he enters the house of God, Hamish wants to make a gesture of respect, however quixotic.

When, in his second stanza, Hamish notes not only 'burnt/out cars' but also signs of a departed horse, he is not engaging in description for the sake of description. In the 1920s and '30s, at least, the Ratana Church was in many respects a modernising institution, and some of its language and symbols were influenced by the United States, a society which was then widely seen as the locus of modernity. The leader of the organisation was called the President, and the automobile was an important symbol of the church. Ratana travelled the country in new-fangled cars decorated with placards bearing his message, and the church sometimes used a picture of a ladder rising out of a Ford convertible toward heaven to dramatise its message that salvation was possible through embracing the world of the twentieth century.

In many rural Maori communities, the horse was until quite recently the main method of transporation. In certain remote and rugged districts, like the East Cape and the north Hokianga, the horse is still commonly used to get to school or to the shops. The ruined cars and departed horse in Hamish's poem represent the abandonment of the temple near Ruawai by both the Ratana faithful and traditional Maori society. If we interpret them with Christian and Ratana theology in mind, the 'hoof-prints' close to the church suggest that evil forces now inhabit the building.

In the last stanza of his poem Hamish brusquely transports us to a Chinese hospital, a place which is full of people, yet which seems just as bleak and lonely as the abandoned temple. Hamish and his partner do not show affection as they move through the hospital, and their concern for the person they have visited - is she a friend, or a mere acquaintance? - seems perfunctory. Like the abandoned temple, the hospital in China is a place to pass through and leave behind. The cosmic title of the poem suggests that Hamish is universalising his message by making the temple and the hospital into metaphors for all human existence. A week and a half ago, after another Smithyman-inspired trip to the Hokianga, I revisited the Ruawai temple, with Skyler, Muzzlehatch, and Eel in tow. A flock of sheep surrounded the building, methodically chewing the damp grass. On the other side of the flaking red door we found mud splattered over stars and moons and sacred words. Muzzlehatch, who was a builder before he was a publisher, inspected the panels of the temple, and declared a number of them to be rotten through.

Returning to the car to retrieve something, Skyler noticed a man with long toned legs and very tight red stubbies herding cattle across the road from the temple. His name was Lockwood Smith, and he owned the huge granary - two lung-shaped iron containers filled with sileage - that dominated the low hill just south of the temple, and seemed to mock the beleagured wooden building with its size and robustness. What happened to the congregation which must once have prayed and sung in the little building outside Ruawai? It is at least possible that some of the faithful were lured into the sort of apostasy which afflicts every successful religious organisation. In 1941 a returned solider named Te Akai Rapana broke with the Ratana Church in protest at its alliance with the Labour Party and its excessive openess to Pakeha culture. The Absolute Established Maori Church - it became known, inevitably, as the Rapana Church - banned its members from drinking, gambling, watching movies, and reading 'undesirable books', and suggested that they live communally in the countryside, away from the influence of the Pakeha. At first the church was based in Te Tii, near Waitangi in the Bay of Islands, where its members ran a mill, but later Rapana led the faithful south to Tinopai, a long peninsula which begins a few kilometres south of Ruawai.

Tinopai would surely have seemed a fine place for a utopian community - the isthmus has its own balmy microclimate, which makes the growing of exotic fruits like olives possible, and the village at its far end sits beside one of the best fishing spots on the Kaipara Harbour. Te Akai Rapana and some of his followers got work on a foresty scheme which was covering some of the peninsula's less desirable land in pines, and they soon raised a meeting house on the outskirts of Tinopai village. Did they win some of the Ruawai congregation to their cause?

There are many examples of Maori comunities allowing religious buildings to decay, because the faith that these buildings represent is no longer strong, or has been transferred to another creed. In his classic study of the Hokianga community of Waima Valley, Patrick Hohepa describes how an historic meeting house was allowed to rot, because the extended family which had used it had embraced the Seventh Day Adventist faith, and erected a new house they judged to be more compatible with that faith.

It is not only Maori communities which are content to live beside the residues of abandoned faith: on a trip to Britain in 2005 I noticed scores of Methodist chapels that had been built in the West Country during the lifetime of John Wesley, only to be eventually converted to thoroughly worldly purposes. In the small Cornish town of Bodmin, somebody had knocked two walls out of an old chapel and converted it into a service station. In the eastern counties of Suffolk and Norfolk a group of concerned - and, it seemed, overwhelmingly non-believing - citizens had formed an organisation designed to protect the round-towered, flint-walled churches that descendants of the Vikings had built in the centuries before the English Reformation.

Perhaps the Round Tower Society is a quixotic, sentimental organisation, and perhaps I am sentimental for feeling sad about the state of the Ratana temple at Ruawai. Perhaps Hamish Dewe's poem, with its images of disorder and transience, is more honest, or at least less sentimental, than the photos of Robin Morrison and Michael Dean. What, after all, is the purpose of a religious building which is no longer inhabited by the souls of the faithful?


Blogger Timespanner said...

My friend Liz and I did some research into the old church building, just down off Otuhianga Road, late last year (we had visited and photographed it back in 2006). I do have a Land Information NZ plan dating from a 1917 survey which shows the church on itsv site, so it predated Ratana. Rather than Anglican influences, I would say it is more likely it may have been one of Rev. William Gittos' service bases -- although whether it is on original site is unknown. A small set of whares existed just to the north on the same piece of land titled "Parerau ewha" (which stretched beyond to the other side of the main highway, a latter-day addition.) On the other side of the highway, the plans indicate an urupa. I'm still keen to see any further information on the building.

8:36 am  
Blogger Edward said...

It is sad to see it in such disrepair. I've often noticed the church on my travels to and from Dargaville and wondered about it. I don't think it's sentimental to wish to conserve aspects of NZ's past at all, but you do raise the very real question as to what is the point in these buildings if no one uses them. In heritage architecture, a building's conservation can often only be realized and sustained if the building is used to some end, preferable an end reflecting at least loosely its original purpose. I suppose we can't save them all.
Unfortunately, as I emailed you, I don't think this building has any protection offered as it's post 1900 and thus outside of automatic protective legislation. Have you managed to find out any more about it?

10:03 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

hamish dewe sounds like an amazing larger than life character.
is there any way of meeting him or has he disappeared again?
and has he published a book?

11:05 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

thanks maps for unpacking some of the background to that terse little piece, and for (as usual) conflating events at a distance of some years into a version of events somewhat more compelling, perhaps even more (psychologically) true, than the real. By the way, Liu Wu is a man. Last I heard of him, he was teaching at a mid-range university in Chongqing (formerly part of Sichuan province). But that was many years ago now.


3:37 pm  
Blogger Richard said...

Great post again Maps. And a fascinating poem. A poem in the trad and almost the spirit of Smithyman himself.

Great poem hd!

(Hamish studied the other HD so that is probably another reason he signs himself 'hd' = Hamish Dewe of course. NOT or not only Hilda Doolittle the major US poet.)

I recall visiting the mother of friend's friend who was Maori and she told me she was of the Ratana faith or church - this was about 1971 or so. It was on the south side of the Hokianga.

There is nothing wrong with the emotion & sadness felt at such places. Such feelings help people to connect to the past and to what they are...good the connection to China. Wystan Curnow did a dual thing in some of his poetry ro writings connecting himself between the US and NZ and Smithyman made a similar connection between England and NZ or Canada and NZ etc

"Everything must be remembered, even the murder of a spider."

10:27 pm  
Blogger maps said...

Thanks very much for the information, Timespanner - I'm afraid you've shown my 'research', which consisted of a couple of google searches, up! I'm in at the library today, so I'm going to seee if I can find any information about the temple in Keith Newman's massive book about the Ratana movement. I'd love to know more about the Rapana Church, too.

Perhaps, though, the people associated with the temple at Ruawai and the Rapana community at Tinopai don't want their stories to become public, yet - that's something that outsiders like myself have to respect.

9:20 am  
Blogger Timespanner said...

I agree, Maps. Still, if ever more info does come to light -- I hope I'm around to read it.

2:25 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Maps is a political pig.

The solution to the Pakeha PROBLEM is...


6:17 pm  
Blogger Ra said...

Kia ora Maps,

Im interested in the information who have on Te Akai Rapana and his church? Do you have any references?
As I cant find anything on it.

2:17 pm  
Blogger Liz said...

Hi Maps

As Timespanner said she and I visited this little church in 2006. Last year however on my way to Dargaville I stopped to help a local Maori family to get their cattle down part of State Highway 12 from Otuhianga Rd. Minnie the Grandmother knew all about the little church. It seems sure enough Reverend William Gittos did have a lot to do with that little chapel. According to Minnie the little church came from Helensville in 1884 ( I do vaguely recall the notation in one of the Church Histories in Helensville of this ocurring however I certainly would not state that as verified evidence. I will find the book concerned and see if there is a reference. There is a plan to restore the church so Minnie had told me and as I understand Historic Places Trust is involved with a conservation plan. I intend contacting Stuart Parks of HPT to see if there is any progress on this. So no the little church was originally Wesleyan Methodist rather than Ratana.

Thanks Maps really enjoy your posts

6:56 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...







6:55 pm  
Blogger Makomihi said...

Kia ora. If you are researching the Absolute Maori Church movement further then you might like to speak with Bert Mackie of Te Puna Kokiri Head Office in Wellington. He is of this faith and his Aunt was married to Rapana. I don't have contact details unfortunately but I suggest that you'd have to 'get a hurry on' as Bert is quite elderly (in his eighties) and is slowing down a bit (although still going to work). He has a remarkable memory and wuold be well worth interviewing on this topic.

3:59 pm  
Blogger 2 Waters said...

The building is not abandoned and as Minnie states is correct. In my youthful years I went to church here with my grandmother and Minnie's father.
There are not many people of the haahi left behind on the land. Especially the elderly whom were strong in the faith. It has been in operation for some years to get the church restored, and its a shame it was not done many years before our kaumatua and kuia passed. The funding has not been forthcoming.
I was saddened to see the title, especially when I knew where all the pictures belong to. I understand you are only sharing but please be mindful, this church carries memories of our loved ones that have passed.

11:17 pm  
Anonymous Scott Hamilton said...

Hi Water2, apologiees for the title of the post, which I can change. I was actually given more information about the place back in 2010, and wrote a new post to explain that restoration work was being done:
Send me an e mail at shamresearch@yahoo.co.nz if you'd like to talk more about all this. I think the church is marvellous and am pleased it's being preserved.
Cheers Scott Hamilton

9:29 pm  
Blogger Unknown said...

Kia ora u all,

Yes, u r correct, the RAPANA church did begin in Te Tii Mangonui (Kerikeri) and I can vouch for it because I am from Te Tii myself but I am not of that faith.....I am of the Ratana faith. Both religions existed in Te Tii (side-by-side literally, like army camp huts). Mr Rapana moved back to Tinopai (not certain of the year) and set up the church HQ there.

The Rapana church still exists today but it's members are also dwindling due to the ageing process and employment prospects. Most families have moved to Auckland to find work and live permanently.

I endorse the comments regarding Mr Rapana's directives to refrain from bad reading materials, similarly with shows that were mentioned, beverages, language .... the information about "no association with pakeha" is new to me tho, hmmmmmmmn.

A point of interest to all, Mr Rapana and Mr Teri Te Heihei (who was the District Apostle of the Ratana church in Te Tii those days) were both elected by T W Ratana
in his original 12 Apostles (being the executive branch of the Ratana church) at the outset. I do also recall (being just a boy then, probably 6/7yrs old)seing a model of a temple similar to the Mormon designs today in the Rapana church hall. Their church was right next door to the Ratana church hall also. Hope this info tickles ur interest somewhat.

Just the same though, I've always wanted more info about the Rapana HQ regarding especially birth death records they maintained as my relations of that church back in Te Tii are not able to assist because they are all too young and unfamiliar with that period. Besides, those that are, are all passed on now.

kia ora mai koutou.

He Paapahu!

10:31 am  

Post a Comment

<< Home