Sunday, April 16, 2006

The peculiarities of the pro-war 'left'

For certain sections of the British media, twenty people sitting in a London pub is news - that is the conclusion that must be drawn, it seems, from the response to the Euston Manifesto, which appears to be the latest attempt to make the term 'pro-war left' seem like something other than an oxymoron.

I personally think that, these days at least, the pro-war 'left' ought to be of more interest to sociologists and pyschologists who study unusual ideas than to newspapers and bloggers. Reproduced below is a paper on the pro-war 'left' which I gave to the 2004 conference of the Sociological Association of Aotearoa New Zealand, and which was republished in the most recent issue of Red and Green, the journal of analysis and theory published (offline, alas) by members of the Alliance Party.


On the 3rd of March 2003, less than three weeks before the invasion of Iraq, the New Statesman published an interview with John Reid, the chairman of the British Labour Party and a Minister without Portfolio in Tony Blair’s government, under the headline ‘Iraq will be a Socialist War’. The talk between Reid and New Statesman political editor John Kampfner was just a skirmish in the vast propaganda war waged by the Blair government in the first months of 2003, as it tried to sell an invasion of Iraq to a sceptical public.

There was a division of labour in this campaign: Blair, his Foreign Secretary Jack Straw and other big guns focused on the alleged dangers of Weapons of Mass Destruction, while Reid, a former member of the Communist Party of Great Britain with longstanding ties to the trade union movement, or at least the bureaucracy of the union movement, was one of the unfortunates assigned the task of winning over unhappy Labour Party members with the ‘left-wing’, ‘humanitarian’ case for war. Pressed by Kampfner to explain the basis for his support for a war, Reid insisted that:

[I]t’s a thing called socialism…we are socialists because we believe in society and mutual interdependence…it’s long been a tenet of social democracy, of democratic socialism, to view with contempt all forms of fascism.

Reid’s argument raised some readers’ eyebrows. In a letter published on the 17th of March, a bemused Peter Horne of Oldham, Lancashire asked the New Statesman whether “Under John Reid’s new definition of ‘socialism’, recent converts might reasonably include George Bush, Silvio Berlusconi, Richard Perle and Donald Rumsfeld. I think even Tony Blair could now be persuaded to become a socialist” Horne marvelled.

Reid’s argument was undoubtedly an unpopular one, but it was never his alone. The party chairman was drawing on a set of passionate and nuanced arguments designed by a significant minority of British intellectuals who for months had been determined to justify the coming conflict on left-wing grounds. Reid’s ‘socialist war’ was fought in the columns of Britain’s big newspapers and in cyberspace long before it reached the fields and streets of Iraq.

The ‘pro-war left’, as it came to be known, included high-profile journalists like the Guardian’s David Aaronovitz, the Independent’s Johann Hari, and the New Statesman’s Nick Cohen. Pro-war leftists without such easy access to large audiences have tended to create their own media outlets in the form of weblogs, or blogs as they’re normally known. Populated by names like Socialism in Age of Waiting, A General Theory of Rubbish, Harry’s Place, and Eric the Unread, the ‘pro-war blogosphere’ has provided a fairly continuous stream of commentary on the war and related issues.

Some of the ‘warbloggers’, as they’re sometimes known, belong to ‘traditional’ parts of the British intelligentsia. Norm Geras, for example, is a Professor of Philosophy at Manchester University, a respected Marxologist, and a biographer of Rosa Luxemborg, who runs Normblog in his spare time. But many of the warbloggers as well as the full-time journalists belong to what John Kampfner has called the ‘commentariat’, and are no more familiar with the academy than they are with their local Trades Hall.

The pulling power of the pro-war blogs should not be underestimated. According to its owner, Normblog receives about 9,000 ‘hits’ or visitors every day; Harry’s Place claims to receive over 2,000, and has been regularly cited in the mainstream media. Opponents of the war felt the need to create their own blog, Barry’s Place, to parody the arguments of the pro-war bloggers.

A Very British Cause

If the pro-war left seems strange to us, that’s probably because it is strange. In New Zealand there is not a single newspaper columnist, not a single left-wing politician, not a single academic who has made, in public at least, a comparable case for war in Iraq. Nor has the pro-war left been much of a feature of political debate in other English-speaking nations. Australia boasts a grand total of two pro-war left blogs, and a Labour Party which was distinctly unenthusiastic about the Iraq war. And it is difficult to imagine a member of Bush’s Cabinet, or indeed a Kerry Cabinet, justifying the Iraq adventure as a ‘socialist war’. It is notable that the most famous ‘left-wing’ advocate of the war writing in America is Christopher Hitchens, an expatriate Briton. The pro-war left seems a very British phenomenon.

I’ve been looking at some of the historical references used by Reid and the rest of the pro-war left, in the hope of clarifying a sort of line of descent for this curious phenomenon. I only have time to mention a couple of examples, but I think there’s a tradition, a peculiarly British tradition, to which we can connect the pro-war left.

Marxist imperialism?

A good place to begin is Reid’s claim that ‘Iraq is a socialist war’, a line which must seem to many observers to be even more compromised than the infamous reports of Saddam’s Weapons of Mass Destruction or Iraq’s ties to Osama bin Laden. With its flat tax rate, its breakneck privatisation programme, and its revival of an old Baathist law banning strikes and independent trade unions, George W Bush’s Iraq hardly looks like a socialist paradise. Yet most of the pro-war left continues to support Reid’s ongoing ‘socialist war’. Even more curiously, more than a few of the pro-war blogs have cited Marx and Engels’ Communist Manifesto in support of their shaky case. Remembered today for its impassioned call for the destruction of capitalism, the Communist Manifesto seems like a particularly odd straw to clutch.

It’s often forgotten, though, that Marx and Engels’ most famous text takes a long time to get to punchlines like ‘the free development of each is the condition for the free development of all’ and ‘Workers of the World Unite!’. The first and longest section of the Manifesto is largely given over to an account of the bourgeoisie’s role in massively increasing productive forces, destroying feudalism, rescuing populations from the ‘idiocy of rural life’, and dragging ‘even the most barbarous of nations into civilization’.*

To many intellectuals in nineteenth century Britain, the first section of the Manifesto read less like history than prophecy. The first British Marxist organisation of any size and durability, the Social Democratic Federation, was led by a man who can rightly be called a forebear of today’s pro-war left. Described by Eric Hobsbawm as a ‘gentleman, cricketer, and stockbroker leading the masses toward revolution in a top hat and frock-coat’, Henry Hyndman worried the working class rank and file of the SDF by using the Communist Manifesto to make pseudo-Marxist defences of the British Empire, arguing that Britain’s colonies were the ‘just desserts’ of the British working class. Hyndman’s views found an echo amongst the so-called socialist imperialists of the early Fabian Society.

Both the liberal, pseudo-Marxist and Fabian imperialists – we can gather them together under the heading ‘left imperialists’ – developed a vision of progress which assumed a dynamic, developing economic system – capitalism, and imperialism – which required the ‘civilizing’ influence of what we might call a ‘moral agent’, if it were to develop in a progressive manner, and perhaps ultimately be transcended. The less developed a country, the less room for the civilising mission of socialism. The left imperialists wanted to hitch a ride on the runaway locomotive of nineteenth century capitalism. It is not difficult to detect an echo of their project in today’s pro-war left. A month before the invasion of Iraq Harry Steele, the proprietor of Harry’s Place, raised eyebrows with a post called ‘Milton Friedman, Guru of the Left’. Steele suggested that:

Capitalist modes of production are a prerequisite of moving beyond capitalism. That is a point Marx and Engels made in various of their works. I think that point has been forgotten…

Commenting a year later on the programme of the Worker Communist Party, the largest and most active Marxist party in Iraq, Steele insisted that: ‘This programme is ultra-left. It calls for socialism, but capitalism barely exists in Iraq’.

Hyndman was concerned with nineteenth century Africa and Marxist critics of British imperialism like Belfort Bax, but his line of argument was strikingly similar. It is understandable that Steele does not actually invoke the name of Hyndman. Like a generation of socialists with faith in the dynamism of imperialism, Hyndman saw his reputation and career ruined by World War One, or the First Great Inter-Imperialist War, as it is sometimes more accurately called. That war and the revolutions it provoked pulled left imperialism apart, forcing the leaders of the Second International to choose between workers’ internationalism or ‘blood and soil’. Hyndman chose the latter, and parted company with the anti-war majority of the Social Democratic Federation.

1940 and the ‘people’s war’

The pro-war left rarely discusses World War One, but their arguments are full of references to the Second World War. In article after article and on blog after blog Saddam is likened to Hitler, Bush is compared to Churchill, and anti-war protesters are no better than the ‘appeasers’ of fascism in the late 1930s. Eric the Unread has gone so far as to compare anti-war bloggers to Lord Haw Haw, the British Nazi who broadcast wartime propaganda from exile in Germany. For its part, Harry’s Place likened the fall of Baghdad to US troops to the liberation of Paris in 1944. To understand the significance of these analogies, we need to consider the role of an important minority of British intellectuals on the home front of the Second World War.

Left imperialism had been most popular in Britain and Germany, the two most dynamic economies in Europe. In Germany the experience of defeat, economic ruin, and fascism killed the optimistic, reformist ‘Marxism’ of the Second International’s great revisionist, Eduard Bernstein. But British society emerged from the war intact, if somewhat traumatised, and survived the interwar years without major upheaval. Britain’s crisis came in the middle of 1940, when the sudden fall of first Norway then France and the Low Countries left it isolated and threatened with Nazi invasion. The British ruling class that had personified inertia and stuffy backwardness in the Chamberlain years of the late 1930s was forced to call upon the aid of the left and the labour movement. Labour MPs and trade union leaders entered Churchill’s government, and one of the Spanish Civil War’s ‘red generals’, Tom Wintringham, was brought in from the cold to control a Home Guard which had attracted a quarter of a million volunteers in the first forty-eight hours after the fall of France.

It was in 1940 that the discourse of left imperialism made a dramatic reappearance. Wintringham pronounced the Home Guard a ‘people’s army’, and insisted that World War Two had become an extension of the Spanish Civil War. George Orwell agreed with him, in a stream of influential articles and a small but remarkable book called The Lion and Unicorn: Socialism and the English Genius. Orwell’s argument was simple: if it were to survive, British civilisation would have to adopt socialistic measures like a degree of central planning and workers’ control. Early in The Lion and the Unicorn Orwell predicted that:

If we hold our nerve, then it may be that in a year’s time the people’s militia will be lodged a the Ritz, flying a red flag – and Churchill may be leading it.

Today’s pro-war left does not believe that the war in Iraq puts socialism on anyone’s agenda, but they believe along with Orwell that it is properly ‘socialist’ practice to subordinate criticism of imperialism to the defeat of ‘fascism’. It is no coincidence that Christopher Hitchens last year published an aggressively possessive study of Orwell, and that a quote from the great man adorns the masthead of Harry’s Place.

Orwell’s view that British capitalism and imperialism had no choice but reform reflected the relative decline of his country in the first half of the twentieth century. This decline was highlighted at the end of the war, when the US forced its by-now junior ally to devalue the pound, launch a new Cold War military build-up and begin dismantling its empire. The post-war Labour government Orwell and others had looked towards to turn the ‘People’s War’ into a transformation of British society found itself holding down wages and social spending to pay for the interest on US loans and the costs of rearmament and the Korean War. The contradiction between imperialism and the hopes of its left-wing apologists was once again exposed. Orwell’s long illness and early death saved him the humiliation Hyndman had experienced.

1956 and the birth of moral imperialism

Another talismanic date for the pro-war left is 1956, the year when the revelation of Stalin’s crimes and the Soviet Union’s invasion of Hungary caused enormous splits in the Communist Parties of the West. In Britain, for instance, the party lost 7,000 of its 21,000 members. A small minority of them went on to form what is nowadays sometimes known as the Old New Left – a loose movement best-known for its role in large Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament demonstrations and for the ‘Third Campist’ opposition of some of its most notable leaders to the foreign policy of both Moscow and Washington.

The pro-war left likes to suggest that 2003 was ‘our 1956’, and that the invasion of Iraq was ‘our Hungary’. In their view, the opposition of the vast majority of the left to the invasion of Iraq is the contemporary equivalent of the acceptance of the Soviet invasion of Hungary by a majority of the old Communist Party. This analogy may be dubious in the extreme, but there is no doubt that 1956 and the short-lived ‘Old New Left’ played an important part in the evolution of the discourse of today’s pro-war left.

By the second half of the ‘50s Britain had become a second-rate power, whose economy lagged behind those of its rivals in Europe and whose empire was being steadily dismantled. Hyndman’s colonialism was no longer acceptable even in the mainstream of the Conservative Party, let alone on the left. The Old New Left was reconciled to, and indeed celebrated, the decline of Britain as an imperialist power. But some of the movement’s key thinkers presented a new vision, of Britain as a moral rather than military or economic superpower. In an influential 1960 essay called ‘Revolution’, EP Thompson speculated that:

Should the protest in Britain gain sufficient strength to force our country out of NATO, consequences would follow in quick succession...People would become aware of the historic choice offered to our country, as they became aware during the Second World War...Of all Western countries, Britain is perhaps the best placed to effect such a transition.

Thompson was exhibiting a nostalgia for Britain’s old place in the world, presented in the form of an appeal for the country to become a moral actor of significance on the world stage. Where the left imperialists had once hoped to exercise a civilizing influence on the British capitalist class, Thompson now saw Britain itself as a civilizing influence on the world. Moral imperialism was to replace economic and military imperialism.

Thompson recognised that leaving NATO would prompt economic retaliation from the United States, but he saw the crisis such retaliation would cause as an opportunity to revive the spirit of 1940, and to argue socialistic measures, if not full-blown socialism, were once again necessary. Others who took up the call for withdrawal from NATO, Unilateral Nuclear Disarmament, and an ethical foreign policy didn’t consider the destabilising consequences of such actions, let alone link them to need for any major reorganisation of British society.

The Old New Left and the CND of the late 50s and early 60s are nowadays regarded as ‘utopian’ because, rejecting the rival power centres of Washington and Moscow, they could point to no ‘objective’ force that could give muscle to their vision of an ethical British foreign policy. Indeed, the New Left would spend much of the 1960s and 70s struggling against the excesses of US imperialism. John Reid himself acknowledged this history, telling the New Statesman that ‘I will bow to no one in my anti-Americanism…they were wrong in Vietnam Nicaragua’.

‘The line has been crossed’

For Reid and for many others on the pro-war left, the events that changed the nature of US imperialism occurred on September the 11th, 2001. The fall of the Soviet Union and the end of the Cold War had removed some of the reasons for a reactionary American foreign policy, but it would be ten years before a decisive shift in that policy would be achieved. In the words of Harry Steele:

In a post Cold War world...opposition to the US and liberal democracies in general, comes not from leftist or national liberation movements but from essentially fascistic forces. There is a point where the line has been crossed, where what may have been a progressive outlook in a previous era becomes a fundamentally reactionary position. The date that line was crossed was September 11...

Hitchens has also testified to the importance of September the 11th, telling an interviewer that:

I know exactly which side I'm on, and I knew right away. I felt exhilaration on the 11th of September, and I feel slightly ashamed to say that, in view of the fact that so many people lost their lives that day. But when the day was over, and I had been through the gamut of rage and disgust and nausea and so on -- not fear, I will claim for myself. I'm not afraid of people like that. I'm very angered by them. But there was something I hadn't analyzed when I went into myself, and I was pleased to find it was exuberance. I thought, "Okay, right. I'll never get bored with fighting against these people." And their defeat will be absolute, it will be complete.

It is S 11 and its supposed consequence of a ‘turn’ in US foreign policy toward anti-fascism and the promotion of democracy which has prompted the latest stage in the evolution of left imperialism. For the likes of Harry Steele, it is US imperialism which is today’s dynamic behemoth, the engine of world progress, and it is Britain, not merely the British left and working class, which has a vital role as the moral agent that can ensure the behemoth acts for progressive ends, channelling its powers.

In his interview with the New Statesman, John Reid is explicit: the Bush administration ‘started from...classic Republican isolation’, he concedes, but S 11 ‘brought home to them the need to engage with the world’. Tony Blair’s government, on the other hand, has always been guided by its ethical foreign policy, and has helped George W Bush to see the light. Reid links Britain’s supposed role as a moral actor on the stage of history to its post-imperial status, telling the New Statesman that:

The role a country can play is not just a direct consequence of population or has something to do with the character of a country and its government...people think we’re more democratic than most places...they do think our soldiers are better than most and therefore, I suppose, they are in continual demand.

A strange sort of success

There’s no need, I’m sure, for me to recount here the military and political problems that the Anglo-American occupation of Iraq has encountered. Having equated US foreign policy with anti-fascism, the pro-war left has been particularly shaken by the revelation of human rights abuses by the occupiers, and by evidence of widespread Iraqi opposition to the occupation. A number of pro-war leftists have begun to equivocate, and a few have recanted.

Johann Hari aggressively championed the war on Iraq, and in the salad days after the fall of Baghdad urged a follow-up invasion of North Korea. Soon, though, Hari was calling for the end of the occupation of Iraq, citing opinion polls. Interviewing Christopher Hitchens in The Independent on the 23rd of September, Hari was disconcerted to find his old mentor rejecting the label ‘left-wing’ in favour of identification with neoconservatism. Hari ended his interview by urging Hitchens to ‘return to the left’, but it is likely that neo-conservatism, with its simple equation of the interests of US capitalism and the interests of humanity, offers Hitchens a more coherent and rhetorically defensible perspective than that of the pro-war left. Defending Hitchens’ exchange with Hari on his blog, Norm Geras suggested that ‘Today’s left may not be, after all, such a bad thing to disown’. Hari, for his part, has moved closer to the anti-war left since his interview with Hitchens. In an article published in The Independent on the 21st of January, he urged his erstwhile comrades on the pro-war left to ‘wake up’ and ‘face reality’:

Tony Blair and the liberals who thought we could ride neoconservatism to a better world have been duped. It is painful, but we cannot live in a dream world. Nothing would make me happier than if the most powerful state in the world was committed to spreading democracy and toppling vicious governments. It is not; in many places, it is doing precisely the opposite.

The pro-war left seems to be disintegrating as a coherent political tendency, as its former adherents choose between an uncomplicated neo-conservatism and a return to the ‘old’ anti-war left.

Of course, the pro-war left has gained one powerful recruit since the invasion of Iraq. As late as February 2003 Tony Blair had insisted that he would tolerate Saddam’s remaining in power, if only Saddam would dispose of his weapons of mass destruction. With the discrediting of WMD claims, though, Blair has been forced to echo John Reid’s ‘socialist’ case for the war at a Labour Party conference and in several interviews. The pro-war left has seen its rhetoric enjoy an unprecedented circulation at the very time that its arguments seem under fatal pressure. We might almost say that the left imperialist tradition has been thrown another lifeline by the very failure of imperialism to liberate Iraq.

A warning for the ‘pseudo-left’

It is easy to ridicule to the pro-war ‘left’, and no doubt the likes of Christopher Hitchens deserve nothing but ridicule. It is possible to argue, though, that in its very extremity the pro-war ‘left’ shows up an error which is common, in one form or another, to many of the people and organisations that Hitchens dismisses as the ‘pseudo-left’. In invading and occupying Iraq on the flimsiest of pretexts, US imperialism has shown the world its ugliest face. It is not surprising that almost all of the left has united in opposing Bush’s adventure.

At other times, though, the left has been far from united in its attitude towards the actions of the US and other imperial powers. The Balkan Wars of the 1990s and the invasion of Afghanistan in 2001 split the left, with many groups and individuals supporting some sort of ‘humanitarian’ intervention by the US and/or Europe. The invasion of East Timor in 1999 saw the Kiwi left split between a tiny anti-imperialist camp, and a huge majority prepared to believe that the likes of Bill Clinton and John Howard were acting for ‘progressive ends’.

It would be untrue to say that the Iraq debacle has destroyed all illusions in progressive imperialism. Only months after participating in the invasion of Iraq, the Australian army organised the occupation of the Solomon Islands, in an attempt to speed up the implementation of an IMF ‘reform’ programme which had seen the public sector gutted and effective control of the Ministry of Finance given to Australasian economists. Australia’s recolonisation of the Solomons was urged by the United States, which had been alarmed by French offers of military assistance to the government of the islands. Despite their recent opposition to the invasion of Iraq, large sections of the Australasian left either refused to oppose or actively supported the invasion of the Solomons. The Green Parties of both countries, for instance, applauded the move, with our own Keith Locke calling it ‘long overdue’.

We in New Zealand have our own, homegrown tradition of pro-imperialist leftism to overcome, before we can safely sneer at the absurdities of Hitchens and his British friends.

* Marx would not always hold such a sanguine view of the destruction of pre-capitalist societies. In his Late Marx and the Russian Road (Monthly Review Press, 1983), Teodor Shanin shows that Marx’s careful studies of Russian society, and in particular Russian peasant society, lead him to the belief that economically underdeveloped societies did not necessarily have to become advanced capitalist societies before they could experience socialist revolution.

Echoing the views of some of Russia’s nineteenth century ‘Narodniks’, Marx’s late, unfinished Letter to Vera Zasulich asserted that Russia’s peasant Communes provide a rough model for a socialist society, and could allow the country to leap straight from its nineteenth century mixture of feudalism and underdeveloped capitalism to socialism.

Marx’s optimism about the possibility of revolution in ‘backward’ countries like Russia anticipates Trotsky’s theory of permanent revolution, which showed that the global economy established by imperialism makes socialist revolution not only possible but necessary in the colonial and semi-colonial world. Trotsky’s ideas were adopted by Lenin and the Bolshevik Party in 1917, but fiercely resisted by Second International leaders like Kautsky and Martov, who argued, like today’s pro-war ‘left’, that socialist revolution was impossible in less developed countries. Determined to deny Marx’s final views on the question, Kautsky and his allies made sure that the Letter to Vera Zasulich was suppressed for decades. By the time the text was finally published in 1924, Stalin was busy promoting his theory of a ‘two-stage revolution’, and ridiculing the idea that nations like China could avoid ‘decades of capitalism’ before socialist revolution became a possibility.

The idea of ‘two stage revolution’ became institutionalised in the left, with disastrous consequences. In Aotearoa, for instance, generations of Marxists have antagonised Maori by telling them that the destruction of their economy and culture was ‘objectively progressive’, because Aotearoa could only become socialist after becoming an advanced industrial nation. In reality, nineteenth century Maori quickly established a ‘Polynesian mode of production’, blending features of capitalism and pre-capitalist modes of production to meet Maori needs. Today, the collective ownership of land and collective labour which was a feature of independent Maori states like the Waikato Kingdom and Parihaka endures in residual form in many places, and remains an inspiration for Maori and radical Pakeha alike. Marxists who deny its importance are condemned to irrelevance.

For a more detailed discussion of this subject, see Owen Gager’s ‘Towards a Socialist Polynesia’. Marx’s letter to Vera Zasulich can be read here.


Anonymous Anonymous said...

I haven't had a chance to read the whole piece but what I've seen looks good. I'm not claiming all virtues for the US left, but we have two awful examples of pro-war lefts. First there were the Stalinists in World War II. Their suppression of militancy in the CIO made it easy to isolate them later and claim, with some truth, that they were an alien element in the working class. Later there were the former Trotskyists and their sympathizers around Max Schactman who ended up as "left wing" supporters of the Viet Nam war.
Then there's the Viet Nam war itself. Many liberals were just plain upset that we lost that war. After committing monstrous acts, there was no way to justify them later, because they didn't work.
I'll bookmark this post and finish up later. Thanks for your efforts.

10:03 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

A very good summary and history of pro-war left views. Readable and cogent, I learned a lot from this. Thanks!

2:31 am  
Blogger septicisle said...

Fantastic post. The kind of thing that makes reading the Euston manifesto worthwhile. (That's a compliment.)

5:28 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This analysis demonstrates an amazing overlap with views that I have been putting forward for over a decade with particular emphasis on Karl Marx's late writings as interpreted by Teodor Shanin. I also think that Belfort Bax's polemics against Bernstein are relevant to the discussion of Henry Hyndman. Here's a snippet from a chapter of a book on imperialism that I was planning to write with Mark Jones, a long-time friend and comrade who died much too young of cancer.
In a December 21, 1897 Neue Zeit article (Colonial Policy and Chauvinism), Bax rejected the idea that capitalism would benefit the "savage and barbaric races." (Unfortunately, the use of such terms was made acceptable by their presence in Engels's "Origins of the Family, Private Property and the State.") What are the consequences of the penetration of capitalism into precapitalist societies? Bax, who if alive today would have likely protested in Seattle or Quebec, writes:

"To begin with, let us ask what might actually be meant by the expansion of modern civilisation which Bernstein, in concert with the average bourgeois Philistine, commends so highly.’ It means, firstly, the sudden advance of the capitalist form of economy, usually in its crudest form, and the simultaneous suppression of the indigenous agricultural economy and civilisation — first and foremost, of course, the suppression of the prevailing mode of production and the current method of exchange. The old ways of organising labour are, as a rule, forcibly destroyed. A variety of religious and philanthropic pretexts are used to eliminate the structures of the old economy as well as the old religious practices and folk customs." (Marxism and Social Democracy, p. 140-141)


2:47 am  
Blogger Shuggy said...

I'm obsessed with oddball political tendencies

It is perhaps this disposition that has led you to produce this account of the Euston group, which bears very little relation to the reality.

I'm not being sarcastic when I say I found your article very interesting but since it addresses a group that exists largely within the confines of your imagination, much of it is fairly irrelevant.

I say this because you have artifically narrowed what is identifiably a broad chruch grouping - too broad for some of the left who otherwise shared our view on the invasion of Iraq - in order to impute to it the status of a cult. You do this in two ways:

1) You (deliberately?) ignore the simple fact that not all of its signatories - indeed, not all of its founding members - supported the military intervention in Iraq.

2) You also incorrectly identify it as consisting of socialists/Marxists - or to you, apostate socialists of the variety you sketch in your post. This afforded you the opportunity to go on about Marx, Engles, Hyndman and god knows who, and while I'm sure that must have been a lot of fun for you, it is largely irrelevant to those amongst the group who perhaps would prefer to describe themselves as liberals and/or social democrats or still more loosely, "progressives".

Rather, the division the Manifesto seeks to identify is not between those who supported the war and those who did not but rather, despite the different views taken on this, between those who find something 'progressive' in making alliances with theocrats, ex-Ba'athists and ultra-nationalists and those who do not. This is obviously not the beginning and the end of the Manifesto, but it is what is sometimes described as a deal-breaker.

I don't know if you're accurately reflecting Reid's view or not but I think you'd find there aren't too many of us that suffer under the delusion that Perle, Rumsfeld or Berlusconi are somehow converts to socialism.

And how unlike a significant swathe of the StWC/SWP/Respect grouping who have managed to convince themselves that the assorted fundamentalist movimentos currently active in the world today are in someway the grave-diggers of imperialist capitalism.

And with what you've written about the Second World War, one scarcely knows where to begin. Probably best not to, except to refer to this:

The post-war Labour government Orwell and others had looked towards to turn the ‘People’s War’ into a transformation of British society found itself holding down wages and social spending to pay for the interest on US loans and the costs of rearmament and the Korean War. The contradiction between imperialism and the hopes of its left-wing apologists was once again exposed. Orwell’s long illness and early death saved him the humiliation Hyndman had experienced.

I genuinely find it difficult to understand what you're going on about here. Is it your contention that history would have humiliated Orwell as a socialist that supported the war against National Socialism and its allies, were it not for the fact of his death? Can it really be your understanding of the economic and social history of postwar Britain that all socialist projects broke on the rocks of austerity, payment of US loans and the Korean war? This is completely bizarre and should leave any reader with any historical sense in no doubt about who it is here that belongs to an "oddball tendency".



Throwing stuff.

You really shouldn't.

3:56 am  
Blogger Lopakhin said...

I agree with much of what Shuggy said. The blogger's comments about Orwell seem to imply that he was soft on imperialism - this is very much belied by, say, his writings on Burma. Many British leftists supported World War Two in the full knowledge that it was likely to end with a much-weakened British empire, in the same way as many people on the Right, from Lord Halifax to Archibald Ramsay, opposed it because (among other reasons) they felt this was more likely to preserve the Empire.

I would just also say that the cartoon which prefaces your article refers to the Hindu Kush, which is in Afghanistan, and is dated 2005. If Steve Bell, or you, believes that the deployment of British troops to Afghanistan late last year was an imperialist venture, then that's your right; I would just add, though, that it's a deployment which enjoys the support of all the main British political parties, including the Lib Dems, who opposed the Iraq war. The British troops there are peacekeepers, operating as part of NATO under the same mandate as the Canadian and German troops sent there in large numbers by the left-wing leaders Jean Chretien and Gerhard Schroder, neither of whom were big fans of the Bush administration.

On Hyndman, if it were the case, as you suggest, that modern pro-war leftists are replicating his arguments, as you set them out here, then the logical consequence of this is that some of them argued for the Iraq war because the oil revenues proceeding from it would benefit the British working classes. I am pleased to report that I neither heard nor read anyone arguing that. Something similar applies to your quoting the letter to Vera Zasulich. I don't know Harry Steele, and can't answer for him, but none of the pro-war leftists I know argued for the war because it would allow Iraq to be turned into a free-market capitalist state which would be a necessary precursor to socialism. Many of them did argue that it should be turned into a democracy, and some of them added that this might provide more promising circumstances for the growth of socialism and trade unionist politics than, say, a dictatorship whose ruler used to feed his politicial opponents into a meatgrinder. Maybe they were wrong, and maybe, indeed, they were credulous to entrust such a task to the Bush government. Maybe you think that we should have laid off the Taleban in Afghanistan too, despite the presence of training camps there from which the 9/11 attacks were planned, because their regime was just around the corner from developing a form of socialism based upon distinctly Afghan institutions. I have to say I find that hard to imagine.

Finally, you quote John Reid, and he is an interesting case of someone who is prepared to say that the US has done bad things in the past. Here's another quote from him: "I opposed the US when it deposed a democratic government in Chile and replaced it with a fascist dictator. I don't see why I shouldn't support it now in Iraq, when it does the exact opposite."

10:22 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Who the fuck is Harry Steele? Someone sold you a bum steer love. The "Harry Steele" business originates from a BNP activist, although given how little concerned you are about 'fascism' it's not surprising that you find brownshirts to be respectable sources of information. The rest you seem to have made up as you went along.

8:15 am  
Blogger unaha-closp said...

Gidday - muddy start - good finish.

Do any of the people involved in these real-life struggles need saving by Norm Geras and the handful of other British bloggers who seem to comprise almost the entirety of the pro-war 'left'? I doubt it.

You doubt it and they doubt it also. They seek to impose a functioning democratic systems of government and you have listed several functioning democracies as examples of things they should not try to change. An amazing degree of symmetry, both you and them praising the functioning of democracy. This is quite disturbing, however you redeem yourself with the following (and indeed the rest of the post).

The authors of the Euston Manifesto have chosen to ignore reality in favour of a blogworld of caricatures; the real-life left will continue to ignore them.

You go on to point out that the imposition of democracy is unjustifiable. Which indeed it is. This is paralleled by the "real-life right" dealing with the ideals of the neo-cons, denigration of this same weak point.

The real life right sees it as much better and much more peaceful to exploit the workers living under non-democratic dictatorships to produce petrol and televisions and computors for our use. A return to realpolitik is called for, a traditional situation of conservatives backing of local strongmen and leftists backing of local unions. The real-life right sees no point in fighting and dying just to give some peasent political power.

Hopefully this pro-war left, neo-con nonsense of pro-democracy will pass by soon.

1:47 pm  
Blogger David J said...

The pro-war left seems to be disintegrating as a coherent political tendency, as its former adherents choose between an uncomplicated neo-conservatism and a return to the ‘old’ anti-war left.

The "pro-war left" is not a 'tendency', it is a temporary alliance between the very different groups you mention.

You've not mentioned the pro-war, pro-revolution line being discussed at Last Superpower, which is another tendency again in the pro-war left - far to the left of the basically liberal Harry's Place.

Long term unity between the vastly different groups in the pro-war left is not the point. Beating back pseudo-left attempts to help the fascists and fanatics win in Iraq is the point.

Human rights abuses by the occupiers don't mean the cause was unjust.

You say there is 'widespread opposition' to the Americans, buthow many people in Iraq voted for parties that advocated armed attacks on US forces?

I'm sure they don't like or trust the Americans, but they know the US forces will _have_ to leave one day - and at least one Iraqi blogger thinks that the US occupation is a lesser evil at the moment. Check his blogroll for others.

BTW, we don't like or trust Bush. We back him when he does a job that needs to be done. On many other things, he needs to be fought.

Regarding your comments that the pro-war left is very small - well, my blog is the third Australian pro-war blog (but I'm closely linked with Last Superpower anyway, so really I'm only about the 2.45th pro-war blog).

But yes, the pro-war left is a tiny minority within a tiny minority.

Despite being outnumbered, we still think overthrowing a fascist like Sadaam was something that leftists are proud of, and that leftists need to support the Iraqi people - who have shown by the purple fingers of free elections who speaks for them.

Orwell was right to argue against pacifism and for an armed working class. His dreams were not based on a real analysis of what people wanted - after the war, English working class were happy to settle for a reformist Labour government, pensions and the NHS.

But he knew that defeating Hitler came first.

Just as soon as the fascist insurgency in Iraq is defeated, will be the time - if the Iraqi people have the will and the strength - to turn against the USA's position in Iraq.

Not a day before.

I don't think the USA can stay in Iraq against the active will of the majority of Iraqis anyway.

10:26 pm  
Blogger ejh said...

Early in The Lion and the Unicorn Orwell predicted that:

"If we hold our nerve, then it may be that in a year’s time the people’s militia will be lodged a the Ritz, flying a red flag – and Churchill may be leading it."

Scott, you've just 'quoted' this again on Lenin's Tomb.

I have searched the online version, I have looked through my print copy and I have tried Google searches using various parts of the quote. I can find no evidence that that Orwell ever wrote this passage, in The Lion And The Unicorn or anywhere else.

There would be no point in fabricating a quote from such an easily checkable source, so it can't be deliberate, but were you relying on your memory and it's let you down in a big way?

Or am I making a grotesque error myself?

9:23 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

my country right or left

"If I had to defend my reasons for supporting the war, I believe I could do so. There is no real alternative between resisting Hitler and surrendering to him, and from a Socialist point of view I should say that it is better to resist; in any case I can see no argument for surrender that does not make nonsense of the Republican resistance in Spain, the Chinese resistance to Japan, etc. etc. But I don't pretend that that is the emotional basis of my actions. What I knew in my dream that night was that the long drilling patriotism which the middle classes go through had done its work, and that once England was in a serious jam it would be impossible for me to sabotage. But let no one mistake the meaning of this. Patriotism has nothing to do with conservatism. It is devotion to something that is changing but is felt to be mystically the same, like the devotion of the ex-White Bolshevik to Russia. To be loyal both to Chamberlain's England and to the England of tomorrow might seem an impossibility, if one did not know it to be an everyday phenomenon. Only revolution can save England, that has been obvious for years, but now the revolution has started, and it may proceed quite quickly if only we can keep Hitler out. Within two years, maybe a year, if only we can hang on, we shall see changes that will surprise the idiots who have no foresight. I dare say the London gutters will have to run with blood. All right, let them, if it is necessary. But when the red militias are billeted in the Ritz I shall still feel that the England I was taught to love so long ago for such different reasons is somehow persisting."

7:58 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Misty Lequin is Pro War and Pro Bush

4:46 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Misty Lequin

4:47 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Come see me on myspace!

4:47 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin Misty Lequin

3:05 pm  
Anonymous Term Papers said...

Great info, i glad to see this blog, such an informative article, Thanks for share this.

6:58 pm  
Anonymous Term papers said...

Nice blog, it's quite informative for readers.

5:55 pm  
Blogger Steve Rogers said...

very well says here well done!!!!
One Way Taxi Delhi to Punjab
Delhi To Ludhiana One Way Taxi

7:53 pm  
Blogger Steve Rogers said...

nice article you are doing very well!
Web Designing Course

8:36 pm  
Anonymous ms excel course in delhi said...

Thanks for sharing wonderful post.. this is a very good and useful post...

5:07 pm  
Blogger Unknown said...

if you did it right then it is awesome well done.
SEO Company, Services, Agency in Meerut

Best SEO Company in Meerut

Best SEO Agency in Meerut

Best SEO Services in Meerut

6:28 pm  
Blogger Web Designing Company in Uttam Nagar said...

its wonderful article you are doing very well keep it up!

Home Tutors Near Me

Coaching Classes Near Me

Institutes Near Me

6:02 pm  
Blogger OGEN Infosystem (P) Limited said...

Really amazing information, thanks for your efforts for this blog. If you need creative and responsive Websites, visit Ogen Infosystem Delhi.
Website Development Company in Delhi

5:14 pm  
Blogger letusdo said...

Very informative blog, You have such an updated blog with peace of knowledge.
Free Digital marketing Course in dilshad Garden
Free Digital marketing Course in Shahadra
Free Digital marketing Course in Shalimaar Garden
Free Digital marketing Course in Vivek vihar
Free Digital marketing Course in Aanad vihar

8:29 pm  
Blogger unknow said...

I really enjoyed your blog Thanks for sharing such an informative post.
Indian Bookmarking list
Indian Bookmarking list
India Classified Submission List
Indian Classified List
Indian Bookmarking list
Indian Bookmarking list
India Classified Submission List
Indian Classified List

9:53 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Thanks for this wonderful post. The information in this article is very helpful. We provide a complete suite of integrated event management software aimed at delivering great user experiences and high ROIs to event planners. It is the only ‘App-First’ cloud-based platform to have automated the entire event lifecycle. This unique offering provides exceptional benefits for the event registration software, business matchmaking app, Onsite Event Management Software, lead retrieval app and the overall 360-degree view of the Event Management process. for more info check us out here:

3:50 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Nice Post thanks for the information, good information & very helpful for others,Thanks for Fantasctic blog and its to much informatic which i never think ..Keep writing and grwoing your self

duplicate rc in delhi online
duplicate rc in ghaziabad
duplicate rc in online
duplicate rc in greater noida
duplicate rc in mumbai
duplicate rc in bangalore
duplicate rc in faridabad
duplicate rc in gurgaon
duplicate rc in noida
death certificate online

3:15 am  
Blogger Anamika amber said...

Amazing!!! I like this website so much it’s really awesome. Keep it up
Love shayari

10:22 pm  
Blogger Maarc said...

The discussion which you share in this is very well. Thanks for sharing this all. Keep it up and keep sharing.

Innovation Security Force India are one of the Best Security & Housekeeping Services in Delhi, it is our GREAT pleasure to have an awaited opportunity to introduce ourselves as one of the leading, professionally managed security organization in Delhi-NCR.

Best Housekeeping Services in Janakpuri

9:55 pm  
Blogger Keddy said...

Interesting Post

Pawan Security Services and manpower supplier in Delhi is a top player in the category Security Services in the Delhi. We are famous for Gunman Security Guard Services provider in Bahadurgarh, Delhi.

Gunman Security Guard Service in Bahadurgarh

11:18 pm  
Blogger Edi said...

Ingin memainkan permainan Capsa Susun dengan mudah, segera mainkan dengan menggunakan Aplikasi Hack Judi Capsa Susun.

Cheat Game Onlines
Cheat Judi Bandar66 Online itu99
Agen Judi Casino ituGol
Tips Bermain Togel ituGol
Trik Akurat Bandar Ceme IndoWinBola
Situs Game Casino Online IndoWinBola

9:44 pm  
Anonymous UGC CARE Journals said...

ugc approved jorunals list

1:22 am  
Anonymous What is peer reviewed jorunals list said...

What is peer reviewed jorunals list

1:23 am  
Blogger miftahul huda said...

Looks realy great! Thanks for the post.
Please Visit Our Website:


9:40 pm  
Blogger Hedkey India Pvt. Ltd. said...

Thanks for sharing this article its very nice post keep up the good work.
Digital Video Colposcope, B`ORZE INDIA has established itself world wide as an international and Borze India is an international and highly regarded company production of colposcopes. We provide best and advanced digital Digital Video Colposcope in India.

Contact: +91 8010857576, 9818478899

10:25 pm  
Blogger sanjeev kumar said...

Good Article
One Day courier Delivery
Courier Service in Dwarka

11:29 pm  
Blogger Uniquoe said...

best makeup artist in gurgaon

best makeup academy in gurgaon

best digital marketing services in delhi

seo services in delhi

ppc services in delhi

app store optimization

website designing service in delhi

web developement service in delhi

12:51 am  
Blogger Reena said...

Thanks for provide great informatic and looking beautiful blog, really nice required information & the things i never imagined and i would request, wright more blog and blog post like that for us. Thanks you once agian

court marriage in delhi ncr
court marriage in delhi
court marriage in noida
court marriage in ghaziabad
court marriage in gurgaon
court marriage in faridabad
court marriage in greater noida
name change online
court marriage in chandigarh
court marriage in bangalore

11:56 pm  
Blogger Unknown said...
pulsa paypal
dana via paypal
top up ovo via paypal
beli saldo ovo via paypal
beli saldo ovo via paypal
beli saldo ovo via paypal
beli saldo ovo via paypal

9:34 pm  
Blogger Yourdoorstep said...

Thanks for provide great informatic and looking beautiful blog, really nice required information & the things i never imagined and i would request, wright more blog and blog post like that for us. Thanks you once agian

name change procedure in india
name change procedure in punjab
name change procedure in rajasthan
name change procedure in maharashtra
name change procedure in andhra pradesh
name change procedure in lucknow
name change procedure in bihar
name change procedure in chandigarh
name change procedure in karnataka
name change procedure in gujarat

12:00 pm  
Blogger Rohini Shetty said...

it's nice to read such good information!
Want to know about Digital marketing services?
Digital marketing company
Digital marketing nagpur

10:28 pm  
Blogger Mr Rahman said...

Really Nice Post & thanks for sharing Or keep up the good work.
Oflox Is The Best Digital Marketing Company In Dehradun Or Website Design Company In Dehradun

8:38 pm  
Blogger Unknown said...

well written article

nicely explained

web design company in pune

web design company in pune

pune to mumbai cab

pune to shirdi cab
pune to alibaug cab

6:37 pm  
Blogger said...

very nice… i really like your blog…CheapWays Digital Marketing Company in Nagpur

5:48 am  
Blogger grey tony said...

I am virtually impressed about the data you provide for your article. I have to say am enormously crushed by your whole story. It’s not easy to get such exceptional statistics these days. I sit up for staying right here for a long term.

6:37 pm  
Blogger jhonalex said...

Thanks for showing that kind of knowledge on your portal.You have done all good.I love to see you again with some new content.

Cheap Flight

8:15 am  
Blogger Linda Brown said...

Thanks for showing that kind of knowledge on your portal.You have done all good.I love to see you again with some new content.

Airlines Tickets

6:48 am  
Blogger innovativethinkerz - Softwaare Company in USA said...

Thanks for showing that kind of knowledge on your portal.You have done all good.I love to see you again with some new content.

Software Services

Artificial Intelligence

Cloud Computing


Web Development

Mobile Application

1:09 am  
Blogger Vipin Chauhan said...

Thanks for provide great informatic and looking beautiful blog, really nice required information & the things i never imagined and i would like to request, wright more blog and blog post like that for us. Thanks you once agian

single status certificate in punjab
single status certificate in india
single status certificate in uttar pradesh
single status certificate in west bengal
single status certificate in bihar
single status certificate in maharashtra
single status certificate in haryana
single status certificate in kerala
single status certificate in rajasthan
single status certificate

12:26 am  
Blogger Edi said...

Aplikasi Hack Judi Online Indonesia
Download APK Mod Poker V Indonesia
Download APK Mod Casino Online
Download APK Mod IDN Poker
Download APk Mod Slot Games
Daftar Agen Poker Online Joinitu
Daftar Agen Domino Online Joinitu

8:15 am  
Blogger Akash godhmare said...

such a nice blog thsnks for sharing
Check Best Digital Marketing Services in Nagpur

4:22 am  
Blogger Morocco travel said...

Rel tours in morocco from spain. iable 3days tour from marrakech to fes desert . Explore Morocco trips, Berber, British, French, anAd Spanish. marrakech tours Variety of best things to do and see is adverse when you have a trip to Morocco, with a recommended travel Agency in Morocco marrakech to essaouira day trip.

Are you a traveller and would like to visit Morocco? Then, your trip is sure to be hitch-free when you travel through a reliable travel agency to morocco .. morocco luxury trips Variety of best things to do and see is adverse when you have a trip to Morocco, with a recommended travel Agency in Morocco desert tours from fes. lol 4 day desert trips from marrakech . morocco with a.
fes to chefchaouen day trip Variety of best things to do and see is adverse when you have a trip to Morocco, with a Agency in

4:16 am  
Blogger Pakhi Singh said...

great post.

12:37 am  
Blogger mahi megh said...

nice content and great post. Kolkata Escorts
Lucknow Escorts

10:21 pm  
Anonymous web design and development said...

Magnificent site. Lots of helpful information here. I’m sending it to some buddies ans also sharing in delicious. And naturally, thanks in your sweat!

6:59 pm  
Blogger whatsapp plus apk said...

Very informative! dr trust weighing machine

4:16 am  
Blogger Shruthi Kapoor said...

8:52 pm  
Blogger India Real Estate said...

1 BHK Flat In Thane West

9:29 pm  
Anonymous said...

Amazing Website, Love It.

6:36 am  
Blogger Haris said...

Do you want an amazing Logo design? buy logo company with us 75% off.

5:56 am  
Blogger GTS CAB said...

GTS Cab, Garhwal Taxi Service, GTS Taxi +91 921-206-9317 Book a cab from GTS Car Rental, GTS Customer Care Number

Garhwal Taxi Service
Car Rental Service
Dehradun to Delhi Taxi
Dooncab service
Delhi to Nanital Taxi Service
Delhi to Dehradun Taxi

1:55 am  
Blogger Ankit Ron said...

Fantasy Power 11 if you have a good knowledge of Cricket you Can play daily online ,live cricket games,
cricket online games,best cricket games,play cricket online, cricket game online at best cricket games app for android phones to win real
cash and amount to instant approve in your bank or Paytm wallet.
play cricket online

10:22 pm  
Blogger Dipi Kapor said...

9:07 pm  
Blogger Natasha Kolkata said...

12:07 am  
Blogger Amazon my tv said...

Through - how you can connect your mobile phone to Amazon Prime. Through, you can watch your favorite TV shows, series movies. You can watch prime videos anywhere on your device. Users need to create an Amazon account if they don’t have an Amazon account and enter the Amazon my TV activation code to watch Amazon prime videos on your device. |

11:07 pm  
Blogger Upsurge Services said...

This is a great article with lots of informative resources.Very Nice written.all the points should be noted. it is worth reading.also UpSurge Services is one of those unique digital marketing providers in Pune which blends creativity with feasibility.We understand your needs like ours, & our digital experts are dedicated to developing the most effective marketing strategy & its execution to get your marketing and business goals. We are offering a plenty of services like SEO, SEM, SMM, Complete Digital Marketing, Website Design and Development, Domain Registration, Web Hosting, E – Commerce Solutions, Logo,Broucher Design, and other IT related projects.

Website development Company in Pune
social media marketing company in Pune
Digital marketing company in Pune

2:57 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Ivizion Technology is a professional Digital Marketing Agency in Nagpur providing creative and customized online solutions in Nagpur at the best price with client satisfaction.

9:15 pm  
Blogger Upsurge Services said... This is a great article with lots of informative resources. I appreciate your work this is really helpful for SEO Marketers.visit usUpSurge Services is one of those unique digital marketing providers in Pune which blends creativity with feasibility.We understand your needs like ours, & our digital experts are dedicated to developing the most effective marketing strategy & its execution to get your marketing and business goals. We are offering a plenty of services like SEO, SEM, SMM, Complete Digital Marketing, Website Design and Development, Domain Registration, Web Hosting, E – Commerce Solutions, Logo,Broucher Design, and other IT related projects.

10:56 pm  
Blogger fantasypower11 said...

Hello , lovers of cricket welcome to our fantasy cricket application means fantasypower11 which is provide you online cricket information
any time to know all cricket match online ball to ball and over to over play cricket online.
play cricket online

3:49 pm  
Blogger Unknown said...

Pune to Mumbai cab
Pune to Mumbai airport cab
Pune to Shirdi cab
Pune to alibaug cab
Pune to mahabaleshwar cab
Pune to tarkarli cab

4:51 pm  
Blogger locannto said...

2:37 am  
Blogger fantasypower11 said...

Welcome to new generation mobile application live play free cricket game online at fantasypower11 and win real
huge amount by creating your team with 11 players.
cricket online games
play cricket online

12:13 am  
Blogger James Anderson said...

Your Article is no doubt very helpful for me and hope, also for the other visitors. I requested to maintain your standard. Thanks for publishing.

Skip Hire
Skip Hire

11:13 pm  
Blogger James Anderson said...

Your Article is no doubt most friendly for me and hope, also for the other visitors. I requested to continue your level. Thanks for publishing.

Skip Hire Nottingham
Skip Hire Newcastle

12:48 am  
Blogger Medical Journals List said...

श्री हनुमान चालीसा Hanuman Chalisa lyrics
श्री शनि चालीसा (Shri Shani Chalisa)
श्री शिव चालीसा (Shri Shiv Chalisa)
कंप्यूटर A-Z की शॉर्टकट Keys

1:03 am  
Blogger Maxowen said...

It's very nice and informative. Thank you for sharing this knowledge with us. I'm also a blogger who teaches folks about app and software development. You can find my work by clicking here.
Digital Marketing Agency in Pune
Web design company in Pune

11:58 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Like every good thing , Disney Plus has certain issues. For instance, a lot of members have voiced their displeasure about the warning users to go to and login/begin in order to type in an 8-digit number.

2:58 am  
Blogger ankit pilania said...

Welcome to, your number one source for all things Related to Lord Hanuman ji. We’re dedicated to giving you the very best Content of Hanuman Chalisa lyrics in all formats like Pdf,Mp3,Mp4,videos, with a focus on Original info related to lord Shri Hanuman Chalisa in kannada , Puja vidhi, Questions related to lord hanuman.
Founded in 2020 by Great Devotee of Lord Hanuman ji -Ankit Pilania,
“” has come Shiv Chalisa a long way from its beginnings. When Pure Devotee of Hanuman ji Ankit Pilania first started out, his Devotion for “Lord Hanuman Ji” drove them to built a Complete Website of Hanuman Chalisa so that the miracles of Shri Hanuman Chalisa can be spreades out in the whole world. We now offers all type of Info and methods of puja and worship related to Anjaneya Hanuman ji. Devotees of all over the world, and are thrilled that we’re able to turn my Devotion to lord Hanuman into our own website of all devotees of Lord Hanuman. Bhutan Winner
I hope you enjoy my posts as much as Enjoy collect and writing them to you. If you have any questions or comments, please don’t hesitate to contact Me.

11:15 am  
Blogger fareferry said...

Thanks for showing that kind of knowledge on your portal.
You have done all good.
I love to see you again with some new content.

Book Cheap Plane Tickets

10:15 pm  
Blogger cheapbestfares said...

Thanks for showing that kind of knowledge on your portal.
You have done all good.
I love to see you again with some new content.

Air Flight Tickets

12:01 am  
Blogger Medical Journals List said...

GK Questions in Hindi: जनरल नॉलेज (General Knowledge) आज से ही नहीं बल्कि काफी पहले से ही एक रोचक विषय रहा है हर किसी के दिमाग में कुछ न जनरल नॉलेज के सवाल घूमते रहते है। पर आज के समय में जनरल नॉलेज के सवाल बहुत ही उपयोगी हो चुके है क्योकि इसके बिना आज के समय में कोई भी परीक्षा कराना संभव नहीं है। कोई भी सरकारी नौकरी की प्रतियोगिता परीक्षा बिना जनरल नॉलेज के नहीं होती। क्योकि जनरल नॉलेज के माध्यम से प्रतियोगिता परीक्षा में शामिल होने वाले उम्मीदवारों के आइक्यू (IQ) लेवल की जांच की जाती है। तो आज हम इस पोस्ट में आपको कुछ महत्वपूर्ण जनरल नॉलेज (Most Important General Knowledge in Hindi "हिंदी में सबसे महत्वपूर्ण सामान्य ज्ञान") के सवालो के बारे में बताते है जो आपके आगामी परीक्षाओं में काम आ सकते हैं

6:17 pm  
Blogger Dais Isnafirlah said...

Thank you for nice information. please visit our web :

1:07 am  
Blogger Unknown said...

Thank you for article
unimuda Sorong, Indonesia

11:10 am  
Blogger Unknown said... :-The NFL Network owns and operates the NFL Station, an American sports-based pay-TV system.Activate NFL Games on Your Phone & device’s NFL appAs you are on this website then you are also a football enthusiast, and we understand your dedication and craze for NFL. But did you know that now you can stream NFL games online through various platforms like your Fire TV, Apple Tv, Roku, Xbox, and PS4 as well. Isn’t it amazing? So tighten your seatbelt and stick with this blog to the end, and we will explain every minor detail that you need to know for This is going to be an experience that you never have with the NFL.

5:28 pm  
Blogger Techno Raft said...

Fantastic information presented in this article. I really appreciate
IT Outsourcing Companies

4:05 am  
Blogger pendekarmuda said...

thanks for your nice blog and this good informastion for me . . .

5:02 pm  
Blogger fareferry said...

The 'city of love' provides iconically romantic settings for vacationing newlyweds from atop the Eiffel Tower, a stroll through ornamental gardens depicting four different sorts of live in Loira Valley or a sip of champagne in the region where the drink is exclusively produced. The lovely and long list is endless and it's hard sometimes to choose and what to do in each destination.
Book flights to Paris

Book flights to Paris

6:46 pm  
Blogger Arpit gupta said...

Grand daughter

raksha bandhan Movie

11:47 pm  
Blogger sonu yadav said...

nice content bestv content kepp it up.
Kana Yaari Lyrics Viral Song Text In Hindi 2022
Dil Ek Villain Returns Song Text In Hindi
Liger Movie Lyrics Akdi Pakdi Text In Hindi Bollywood Song 2022
Marvel Studios’ Thor: Love And Thunder Review In Hindi 2022
HIT- The First Case Movie Trailer Review 2022 | हिट मूवी
Shamshera Movie Trailer Is Coming 2022:

11:01 pm  
Anonymous Ravi Gupta said...

Very Informative post. Will reach to get some good content in futureArati and chalisa
Shri Gayatri Chalisa

2:54 pm  
Blogger Abhishek Kushwaha said...

Woww i realy need for this article Hindian - Entertainment News , Govt Jobs , Exam Date & Result Thank you..

12:22 am  
Anonymous JBNLive said...

JBN Live a digital news platform that will give you all the news of INDIA which is necessary for you. You will bring all the news related to your life which affects your life.
JBNLive - Top Breaking News and Entertainment News in hindi

7:08 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

USA pone Video
bd sex video
bd sex video ABEE85 CAPCUT
india sex video Spa in dhaka
bd sex video

5:32 pm  
Blogger Outbooks UK said...

Accounting & Bookkeeping Services for UK Accountants. Leading accounts outsourcing company with more than 20 Years of UK accounting experience. outsourcing for accountants

5:08 am  
Blogger Arpit gupta said...

Wow It's really nice information
Drishyam 2
Home Loan

1:56 pm  
Anonymous Sultan singh said...

I feel very grateful that I read this. It is very helpful and very informative and I really learned a lot from it.

4:17 pm  
Blogger Jodhpur Cabs said...

Such a nice blog, thanks for sharing.....
Taxi Service in Jodhpur

12:10 am  
Blogger Dhananjay Bhuyan said...

Very Nice content please visit Best Web Design Training Courses in Pune to learn and get placed in top industries

7:16 pm  
Blogger Nikunjvaria92 said...

Nice Post

10:04 am  

Post a Comment

<< Home