Monday, November 10, 2014

For and against Islamism: the West's hypocritical war in Iraq

[This is a comment I made during a recent facebook discussion about the endless war in Iraq.]

After condemning the violently sectarian politics of the Islamist outfit ISIS, John Key has announced that members of the New Zealand army will be sent to Baghdad to help train Iraq's army. It is hard to think of any gesture less likely to lead to the defeat of Islamism in the Middle East. 

Iraq's government is controlled, after all, by a collection of parties that practice Islamist politics. Where ISIS presents itself as the representative of Sunni Muslims, and kills or enslaves members of other religious groups, the Dawa Party and its allies in the Iraqi government present themselves as the representatives of Shi'a Muslims, and persecute Sunnis and others. Behind the Iraqi government stands Iran, which has been ruled by Shi'a Islamists for three and a half decades.

Dawa and the other Shi'a parties maintain their own militia, which they use to enforce their primitivist interpretation of Islam. Women who dress immodestly, shopkeepers who sell alcohol, and Christian who take communion have all been victims of the militia. The Iraqi army collapsed in the middle of this year, as ISIS conquered much of the north of the country. As troops deserted, they were replaced by members of the Shi'a militia. It is these men that Kiwis troops will be training.

In the name of fighting Islamism, then, John Key is sending New Zealand troops to support an Islamist government in Baghdad and train the armed thugs of this government. Like its American and Australian allies, New Zealand has made a de facto alliance with Shi'a fundamentalism and with the Iranian government.

Such an alliance is, of course, very ironic, because for decades America and most other Western nations have been enemies of the Iranian regime. America took the side of Iraq when Saddam Hussein invaded Iran in the 1980s, and in recent years it has imposed a range of sanctions on the country in an effort to stop Tehran developing nuclear weapons.

To understand why America and its allies have now aligned themselves with Iran, we have to consider the disastrous consequences of George Bush's invasion of Iraq.

When he sent troops across the Iraqi border in 2003, Bush talked about replacing Saddam Hussein with a secular government that would have no truck with Islamist politics. He wanted to create an ally of America in the heart of the Middle East, secure cheap access to the country's oil, and put the Islamist government of Iran under pressure.

But Bush's plan quickly failed, as Iraqis refused to support the pro-Western leaders he wanted to foist upon them. Protesters from Iraq's Sunni community took to the streets with guns. Desperate to find an ally against a resistance movement that was taking dozens of American lives every week, Bush turned to the Shi'a Islamists, and allowed them to take control of the Iraqi state. As America's influence in Iraq has declined, the influence of Iran has grown. Today Obama sees Iran and its allies in the Iraqi government as the only force that can stop ISIS.

But it is another force that is doing most of the fighting against ISIS. In both Iraq and neighbouring Syria, the Kurdish militia known as peshmerga have been defending towns and villages against ISIS's attacks. The Kurds live on the mountainous borderlands between Turkey, Iraq, Syria, and Iran, and have been fighting for independence from the governments of all of those countries for decades.

Unlike the gangs of thugs run by the Iraqi government, the Kurdish peshmerga are secularists. They have defended the Yezidi religious minority against ISIS; they have passed a law calling for the equality of men and women in the region of northern Syria they control. 

America has given some support to the Kurds fighting ISIS. American airplanes, for instance, have bombed ISIS troops besieging the Kurdish town of Kobane.

But America has helped prevent the most powerful of all the Kurdish armies, the Kurdistan Workers' Party, or PKK, from joining the fight against ISIS.

The PKK is based in Turkey, and wants to send some of its thousands of fighters into Syria and Iraq, so that they can confront ISIS. But the Turkish government has bombed and shelled PKK to keep them from crossing the border. America and many other Western nations, including New Zealand, classify the PKK as a terrorist organisation. They have refused to speak out against Turkey's recent attacks on the PKK. Western governments oppose the PKK because they fear offending Turkey, which hosts important American military bases and is an important trading partner for Europe.

If John Key opposed violent sectarianism in Iraq, then he would not support the Islamist government in Baghdad. With its persecution of religious minorities and its roving militia, the Baghdad regime is a Shi'a mirror image of the Sunni ISIS. Key would look to the north of Iraq, and offer New Zealand support to the Kurdish peshmerga. Key would send New Zealand troops to work with the peshmerga, and would condemn Turkey for holding back the fight against ISIS by attacking the PKK.

Sadly, though, John Key is, like Helen Clark before him, more interested in keeping New Zealand on good terms with America than in helping deal with the problems of Iraq and the Middle East.

[Posted by Scott Hamilton]


Anonymous Anonymous said...

Bravo. What a shame we cannot read the same calibre of analysis in the NZ media.

5:53 am  
Blogger Richard said...

The RAF and the Turks bombed the Kurds in the first Iraq war.

But it is a civil war there. Hypocritical US reaction against "terrorism" (the only way in many cases (perceived) to continue a struggle against the highly militarily strong US and its allies. So the ISIS or whoever they are a seen as heroes. Because they are winning. What it means that, as perdicted, the US et al have failed in all their invasions to acheive anything. The NZ army are wasting their time in Iraq in a futile and barbaric war that has nothing to do with us. We need to stay clear.

China and Iran will mop up eventually.

Good post. Interesting. Except that I wouldn't valorise the Kurds too much just because they are "secularist". That wont stop them from being "thugs" any more than any other army. Thugs win wars. War is not a tea party. And political power comes out of the barrel of a gun.

10:55 am  
OpenID ropata said...

Another stupid war that has nothing to do with NZ. Why does the Key Government insist on clinging to the apron strings of faded empires? Follow the money...

2:10 pm  
Blogger Richard said...

Ropata - on the button - it is worth reading Arundhoti Roy on the Indian Government and also her resentment of books such as one recent one extolling 'Empire' and her realisation of the hypocrisy of the Imperialists.

I read the book about the young Australian who was thrown into Guantanamo, which is a terrible place, no doubt like or similar to the Stalinist Gulags or Hitler's holiday camps, but the US boast how free and wonderfully democratic they, if they didn't engender 9/11 - they can forever gripe and moan about freedom and how the 3000 Israeli accountants and a few tourists died (forgetting the millions of civilians the US has butchered since they dropped the atomic bomb in 1945 (twice) - so they probably organised 9/11.

Wonderful for them! And even ISIS? Who is to know they are not behind them? Aiding and abetting? "Who shall rid me of this meddlesome priest?" Henry the II, he didn't have to name Beckett, but it was as good as ordering that priest's death sentence...

Now it is revealed that none of those in Guantamo are anything other than people the locals were paid to provide to the US. No one in their is a "terrorist". The only terrorists are the US and the Israelis and other "faded empires'....

It is a farce. A nonsense. Leave them to their adventures, we don't have to follow them. We could be selling more milk products to the Middle East oil producing countries etc

The US is finished, they cant even control their own workers, they gun down blacks: where is this wonderful free, racially equal nation we should admire who bomb and napalm for freedom? Who are they? They are on the way out...

10:47 pm  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home