Monday, September 05, 2016

Is historical materialism like a condom?

Terry Coggan has written a belated but lengthy and thoughtful contribution to the debate about historical materialism and Pacific history that I started with a blog post back in June. Coggan is a member of the Trotskyist Communist League and the author of a long essay about New Zealand history called 'The Legacy of Primitive Communism'.

The theory of historical materialism was developed by Marx and Engels. They believed that the forms of a society's ideological, cultural and legal 'superstructure' - its ideas, its art, its laws, and so on - are determined by that society's economic 'base' - by the ways that goods are produced and distributed. A feudal society, then, will have a different superstructure to a capitalist society, because its economy is different. Historical materialism explains changes in ideas and culture in terms of economic changes.

In my blog post I suggested that both the ancient and contemporary histories of Pacific societies like Tonga and Papua are hard to explain using the base-superstructure model supplied by historical materialism.

The ancient Papuans discovered agriculture, but did not use it to create the sort of hierarchical, materially wealthy societies found in ancient Mesopotamia and Egypt. The ancient Polynesians sailed from places like Tonga to the remote east of the Pacific long before they had overcrowded or depleted their homelands. And today in societies like Tonga and Papua New Guineas the development of capitalism is frustrated by cultural practices that hark back to pre-capitalist times. Businesses fail because owners distribute profits through extended families and clans, instead of reinvesting them; productivity lags because workers take time off for festivals and harvests.

Terry Coggan uses a memorable image when he insists on the universality of the theory of historical materialism. Like a condom, he says, the theory has to work anywhere and at any time, if it is to be credible. Coggan doesn't deny the anecdotes I offer from Pacific history, but argues that they do not really refute the theory of historical materialism, because that theory is looser, and more tolerant of anomalies, than I had supposed. Read Terry's comments and the rest of the discussion thread and decide for yourself.

[Posted by Scott Hamilton]

6 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

He is right. Your work and outlook are passe. You are desperately trying to find something of value, poaching and intruding on the cultures of others. Nothing you say is original. Get a life, get a job, you will never be a writer or a historian of any value.

6:26 pm  
Blogger James Lackey said...

I like the effective information you bestow in your articles. I’ll bookmark your blog and check yet again at this juncture recurrently. I’m quite definite I will hear several pristine stuff acceptably here! Clear good fortune for the next! Ooh media advertising and web are the two quickest developing media segments. Historically known as outdoor advertising.ooh is contained a few hundred standard advertising arranges that encompass and submerge customers outside the home. Outside advertising permits publicists to appreciate broadened engagement with groups of onlookers in ways different mediums basically can't coordinate.

8:35 pm  
Blogger De Tam said...

Synthetic friv games, unblocked yepi and nothing can replace.
Unblocked, Friv 2, abcya, Yepi, tetris, Y8, Y3, Kizi 6, pbs

10:34 am  
Blogger Brad Hogg said...

I needed to thank you for this extraordinary read!! I unquestionably appreciating each and every piece of it I have you bookmarked to look at new stuff you post. condom malaysia

12:41 pm  
Blogger Master Sgp said...

KAMI SEKELUARGA TAK LUPA MENGUCAPKAN PUJI SYUKUR KEPADA ALLAH S,W,T
dan terima kasih banyak kepada AKI atas nomor togel.nya yang AKI
berikan 4D/ angka [] alhamdulillah ternyata itu benar2 tembus AKI.
dan alhamdulillah sekarang saya bisa melunasi semua utan2 saya yang
ada sama tetangga.dan juga BANK BRI dan bukan hanya itu AKI insya
allah saya akan coba untuk membuka usaha sendiri demi mencukupi
kebutuhan keluarga saya sehari-hari itu semua berkat bantuan AKI..
sekali lagi makasih banyak ya AKI… bagi saudara yang suka main togel
yang ingin merubah nasib seperti saya silahkan hubungi AKI ALIH,,di no (((_082 313 669 888_)))insya allah anda bisa seperti saya…menang togel 2750 JUTA , wassalam.


dijamin 100% jebol saya sudah buktikan...sendiri....


Apakah anda termasuk dalam kategori di bawah ini !!!!


1"Dikejar-kejar hutang

2"Selaluh kalah dalam bermain togel

3"Barang berharga anda udah habis terjual Buat judi togel


4"Anda udah kemana-mana tapi tidak menghasilkan solusi yg tepat


5"Udah banyak Dukun togel yang kamu tempati minta angka jitunya

tapi tidak ada satupun yang berhasil..




KLIK DISINI ANGKA TOGEL JITU 2D 3D 4D 5D 6D




Solusi yang tepat jangan anda putus asah... AKI ALIH akan membantu

anda semua dengan Angka ritual/GHOIB:

butuh angka togel 2D/ ,3D/, 4D/ 5D/ 6D/ SGP / HKG / MALAYSIA / TOTO

MAGNUM / dijamin

100% jebol

Apabila ada waktu

silahkan Hub: AKI ALIH DI NO: (((_082 313 669 888_)))


ANGKA RITUAL: TOTO/MAGNUM 4D/5D/6D/


ANGKA RITUAL: HONGKONG 2D/3D/4D/6D/



ANGKA RITUAL; KUDA LARI 2D/3D/4D/6D/



ANGKA RITUAL; SINGAPUR 2D/3D/4D/ 6D/



ANGKA RITUAL; TAIWAN,THAILAND



ANGKA RITUAL: SIDNEY 2D/3D/4D 6D/







12:44 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Love this blog, Maps! Great stuff! Ignore the haters, and in any event, keep in mind that if your work didn't generate a few, then you know you're doing it all wrong!

1:01 am  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home